Letter from Poetry Magazine

Carmine Starnino Responds

by Carmine Starnino
Carmine Starnino responds:

I feel badly that my “phrase-mongering” caused Beverly Bie Brahic to suffer so. Perhaps in the future she should skip anything with my byline on it. The virile distinctiveness / verbal subtlety contrast was actually intended to break down a cliché. It was part of a larger point I was making about Boland’s originality, and in her matchup with Heaney I award her all the points. In fact, it’s breathtaking to be accused of an ad hominem attack for a review that uses up most of its word limit carefully enumerating Boland’s many achievements. True, I don’t think much of her new work—nor Harry Clifton’s, for that matter. But Brahic’s characterization of my criticisms as “put-down[s]” seems driven by the conviction that the best way to get smarter reviews is to enforce more courteous reactions. This (to paraphrase the late Tom Disch) is just another form of censorship—censorship by civility, by politeness, by arbitrary standards of so-called disinterestedness. Brahic assumes readers need to be protected from the sinister seductions of confident critics, but no reader is really that innocent. Which is to say, lighten up. Reviews dwell in a discretionary realm: you can choose to refuse anything in them.
Originally Published: January 30, 2009

Poetry is looking for thought-provoking responses to work published in the magazine, as well as letters that raise new questions about the state of contemporary poetry. To send us your letter, please fill out all the fields below.

If we choose to use your letter, we will notify you by phone. If you have not heard from us within two weeks of sending your letter, you may assume we will not be using it. All letters may be edited for length and clarity, and may appear online, in print, or both.

Please do NOT send poetry submissions to this account. See Submission Guidelines for further information and policies regarding poetry submissions.


* All fields are required


This prose originally appeared in the February 2009 issue of Poetry magazine

February 2009


Audio Article
 Carmine  Starnino


Carmine Starnino’s books of poetry include The New World (1997), Credo (2000), With English Subtitles (2004), and This Way Out (2009). He is also the author of A Lover's Quarrel (2004), a book of essays on Canadian poetry, and is the editor of Signal Editions. He lives in Montreal.

Continue reading this biography

Originally appeared in Poetry magazine.

This poem has learning resources.

This poem is good for children.

This poem has related video.

This poem has related audio.