1. Home
  2. Poetry Magazine
  3. Brian Phillips Responds by Brian Phillips
Letter from Poetry Magazine

Brian Phillips Responds

Brian Phillips responds:

Well, I don't know. R.S. Gwynn sounds very outraged, but I'm not sure he's really accusing me of much. Using brief, representative quotations? Portraying a book as part of a general trend? If Gwynn truly objects to these standard reviewing practices, he's going to have a lot of letters to write. But I'm afraid he simply misreads my review of Ted Kooser, which argues nearly the opposite of what he says; and when he insinuates that I pose some sort of threat to Richard Wilbur, he does so purely for effect. (Wilbur's work, which I deeply admire, was mentioned nowhere in my piece.) Gwynn's charge seems to come down to the fact that I disagreed with his published reviews of these poets. But why write a letter about that? Gwynn's reviews are readily available elsewhere, as are mine in this magazine. I would simply encourage interested readers to look at both, and judge for themselves.

More from this issue

This poem originally appeared in the April 2005 issue of Poetry magazine

Letter from Poetry Magazine

Brian Phillips Responds

Other Information

  • Browse Poems

    loading...