Over the Moon

Colleen McElroy's women go on and on, courageous and grim.

by Valerie Trueblood
Colleen McElroy once wrote a poem in which the machines—pistons and cylinders—rose up and ate the people. Mostly, though, what does the mauling and eating-alive in her work is love. That’s the case in her new collection Sleeping With the Moon, her tenth, published last year by the University of Illinois Press.

Sleeping With the Moon
By Colleen J. McElroy
University of Illinois Press
136 pp., $19.95
Only occasionally does love come as an amelioration; instead, in these poems, it is “the bruise of fingers,” “the insult of loss,” “the disease of fondling,” the thing that breaks into the “house of thin composure.” Sometimes its selfish excitement hardly differs from anger, its loneliness from “three months in Virginia / looking at the weather channel.” It’s a tale told in ex-wives, a raw engagement overheard through the wall. Its product is new lives to be broken into or broken: the bed in the anguished title poem is a sleeping bag in a cold doorway. Yet throughout her work, whenever it shows its face, what a welcome love receives.

Though a teacher, McElroy is of no school; though a storyteller, she would laugh at the confines of plot; though a born skeptic and ironist, she is not afraid to show herself thrilled by love. As the title suggests, much of Sleeping With the Moon takes place in bed, or thinking back on bed (“don’t confuse writing of love and finding it”). A book with such emotional material and such a long memory—girlhood in the 1940s comes to life in “Some Are Dead and Some Are Living”—must steer clear of bitter hindsight or the reverse, nostalgia. McElroy’s approach to her own past and to people undergoing what’s likely to turn out badly calls to mind the matter-of-factness of Colette, as does the intensity, proudly female, that she brings to the position of outsider, wanderer, watcher drunk on the sights, sufferer likely to be found dancing.

She will happily give the MFAs a headache with her unfashionably clear statements and heartbroken admissions and the bold planting, in almost every poem, of the moon, which she annexes to her purposes, only sometimes romantic. It can shine as purely as it does on the cover of her book, yet a mind troubled by history plays over moonlit scenes of dancing and women confiding in each other and sexual love. “[T]hose little quirks carried to bed” will show up, not to mention the whole world of night, with its “cold / hard bed of streets” in which a loved one huddles in the powerful “Codex: Frostbite.”

Recently a female novelist told an interviewer, “A woman’s narrative stops as soon as she begins to have children.” I can hear McElroy’s belly-laugh at that. The women in these poems go on and on; their narratives do not come to a gentle halt in domesticity or motherhood, or in illness or chemo or loss. McElroy is a short-story writer; a word or gesture forces on her a whole history: the disordered interiors of home life and the struggle going on there, courageous and grim. Read “I Speak to the Girl Some Dim Boy Loves,” and shiver at a novel told in 30 lines.

Despite its quarrels with life, the book is in a major key. Its ground note is everyday beauty, of moments, bodies, places, things said and done: beauty gathered with the usual poet’s hunger and mourned when cruel events eclipse it or it simply runs out. But in addition, beauty here is a kind of added sense, experienced from inside as a state of being—the way a person found beautiful, one who has had “the power to choose // which way the wind blows,” experiences its cycle over a long life.

Woman’s experience is at the center of the book. Men come in for comic scrutiny, though as workers, soldiers, and lovers they get some respect and a comradely pity. For a book about love and beauty, Sleeping With the Moon covers a lot of ugly ground, from union-busting to the ordeal of a vagrant who must change his pants in public to a close-up of labor in a copper smelter (“it’s slag work slopping/around in tanks ten feet deep / in copper slime and hoping // overtime makes up for the loss / of breath”). Aging and illness get no gilding. McElroy casts a cold eye on the past “where Indians were chased for the hunt” and black men fought “for a country willing to forget them.” And she doesn’t let herself off the hook.
We are the learned few, the two or three
Who make the rules, who read the books
That tell us how humane we’ve made this life.
Originally Published: April 16, 2008


On April 18, 2008 at 1:22pm Jeannine Hall Gailey wrote:
Thanks for this! One of my favorite poets. Colleen is proof that a poet can also be a true storyteller.

On May 13, 2008 at 3:10pm Nana Adu Dwuma Bismark wrote:
very interesting poetry and educative,i want more of it.pls sent them throught my mail.

POST A COMMENT welcomes comments that foster dialogue and cultivate an open community on the site. Comments on articles must be approved by the site moderators before they appear on the site. By submitting a comment, you give the Poetry Foundation the right to publish it. Please note: We require comments to include a name and e-mail address. Read more about our privacy policy.



Valerie Trueblood lives in Seattle. Her novel Seven Loves came out from Little, Brown in 2006.

Continue reading this biography

Originally appeared in Poetry magazine.

This poem has learning resources.

This poem is good for children.

This poem has related video.

This poem has related audio.