This kind of poetry, which unveils the poet's innermost feelings, is usually termed confessional poetry, and it is the subject of much critical controversy. A Times Literary Supplement reviewer, for example, said of Live or Die that "many of Mrs. Sexton's new poems are arresting, but such naked psyche-baring makes demands which cannot always be met. Confession may be good for the soul, but absolution is not the poet's job, nor the reader's either." A Punch critic added, "When her artistic control falters the recital of grief and misery becomes embarrassing, the repetitive material starts to grow tedious, the poetic gives way to the clinical and the confessional." Many reviewers raised at least two questions. First, should her poetry be classified as confessional? Second, does her work consistently demonstrate the artistic control which many critics feel is an essential quality of good poetry?
Concerning the first question, Erica Jong objects to the classification: "Whenever Anne Sexton's poems are mentioned, the term 'confessional poetry' is not far behind. It has always seemed a silly and unilluminating term to me; one of those pigeonholing categories critics invent so as not to talk about poetry as poetry.... The mind of the creator is all-important, and the term 'confessional' seems to undercut this, implying that anyone who spilled her guts would be a poet." Sexton also often denigrated the term, but at times she applied it to herself. She told Berg that "for years I railed against being put in this category. Then ... I decided I was the only confessional poet." Moreover, in an interview with Patricia Marx, Sexton discussed the effect on her work of another poet often called confessional, W. D. Snodgrass, and acknowledged the confessional quality of her writing: "If anything influenced me it was W. D. Snodgrass' Heart's Needle.... It so changed me, and undoubtedly it must have influenced my poetry. At the same time everyone said, 'You can't write this way. It's too personal; it's confessional; you can't write this, Anne,' and everyone was discouraging me. But then I saw Snodgrass doing what I was doing, and it kind of gave me permission."
The second question is perhaps best answered in critics' specific responses to several of her individual books. Like many of Sexton's volumes, To Bedlam and Part Way Back received a mixed response. Dickey praised the subject of the work, but found that "the poems fail to do their subject the kind of justice which I should like to see done.... As they are they lack concentration, and above all the profound, individual linguistic suggestibility and accuracy that poems must have to be good." On the other hand, Melvin Maddocks believed that "Mrs. Sexton's remarkable first book of poems has the personal urgency of a first novel. It is full of the exact flavors of places and peoples remembered, familiar patterns of life recalled and painstakingly puzzled over.... A reader finally judges Mrs. Sexton's success by the extraordinary sense of first-hand experience he too has been enabled to feel." Barbara Howes thinks that many of the poems are flawed, but overall she judged Bedlam "an honest and impressive achievement."
All My Pretty Ones also garnered mixed reviews. Peter Davison found one poem, "The Operation," "absolutely superb," but he felt that none of the others are nearly as good. Dickey's critique was even stronger: "Miss Sexton's work seems to me very little more than a kind of terribly serious and determinedly outspoken soap-opera." Yet in an essay on both Bedlam and Pretty Ones, Beverly Fields argued that Sexton's poetry is mostly misread. She contended that the poems are not as autobiographical as they seem, that they are poems, not memoirs, and she went on to analyze many of them in depth in order to show the recurrent symbolic themes and poetic techniques that she felt make Sexton's work impressive.
Dissent among the reviewers continued with the appearance of Live or Die, Sexton's best known book. A Virginia Quarterly Review critic believed that Sexton was "a very talented poet" who was perhaps too honest: "Confession, while good for the soul, may become tiresome for the reader if not accompanied by the suggestion that something is being held back.... In [ Live or Die ] Miss Sexton's toughness approaches affectation. Like a drunk at a party who corners us with the story of his life,... the performance is less interesting the third time, despite the poet's high level of technical competence." Joel O. Conarroe, however, had a more positive view of Sexton's candor. "Miss Sexton is an interior voyager," commented Conarroe, "describing in sharp images the difficult discovered landmarks of her own inner landscape.... Poem after poem focuses on the nightmare obsessions of the damned: suicide, crucifixion, the death of others ..., fear, the humiliations of childhood, the boy-child she never had.... It is, though, through facing up to the reality (and implications) of these things that the poet, with her tough honesty, is able to gain a series of victories over them.... All in all, this is a fierce, terrible, beautiful book, well deserving its Pulitzer award."
Transformations, a retelling of Grimm's fairy tales, marked a shift away from the confessional manner of her earlier work, which several commentators found to be a fruitful change. Gail Pool, for example, contended that the tales provided Sexton with "a rich medium for her colorful imagery," a distance from her characters which allowed wit, an eerie realm "where she had always been her sharpest," and "the structure she needed and so often had difficulty imposing on her own work. At last she had found material to which she could bring her intelligence, her wit, all that she knew, and she created, in Stanley Kunitz's words, 'a wild, blood-curdling, astonishing book.'" Christopher Lehmann-Haupt echoed Pool's analysis, arguing that Sexton's earlier work tended to lack control, that perhaps she worked too closely with firsthand experience. Lehmann-Haupt continued, "by using the artificial as the raw material of Transformations and working her way backwards to the immediacy of her personal vision, she draws her readers in more willingly, and thereby makes them more vulnerable to her sudden plunges into personal nightmare." Similarly, Louis Coxe discovers a new objectivity and distance in Transformations, which he considers "a growth of the poet's mind and strength."
In The Death Notebooks, The Awful Rowing toward God, and 45 Mercy Street, the last two published posthumously, Sexton returned to the confessional method. While these books have been praised, they have also been more severely criticized than her early writings, many readers detecting a deterioration in quality. William Heyen remarked that Sexton's "poems went almost 'steadily downhill, became less intense, less dramatic, less interesting as one book followed another.... There were moments, occasional lines or even poems that wept or raged with her old power," but overall her voice became often "maudlin or patently melodramatic or simply silly." Heyen added that Awful Rowing continues the downward trend; it is touching, "but it's not very good." Robert Mazzocco seconded Heyen, commenting that while the early poems "depict intensely introverted states in highly extroverted style" and are well constructed, the later poems "seem to me less commanding, strike dissonant strains, chromatize the keyboard, or become programmatic." In like manner, Patricia Meyer Spacks argued that Sexton's poems become more and more sentimental in that they overindulge in emotion and fail to evaluate that emotion. The sentimentalism becomes "painfully marked" in Awful Rowing, "with its embarrassments of religious pretension.... The problem of internal division, the perception of divinity, the will to rebuild the soul: all alike register unconvincingly. The poetry through which these vast themes are rendered is simply not good enough."
On the other hand, not all critics disparaged the later books. In a response to Spacks's critique, Jong commented: "Let's be fair about Sexton's poetry. She was uneven and excessive, but that was because she dared to be a fool and dared to explore the dark side of the unconscious." Moreover, Sandra M. Gilbert believed that The Death Notebooks "goes far beyond [the earlier volumes] in making luminous art out of the night thoughts that have haunted this poet for so long." Finally, Jong, in a review of Notebooks, assessed Sexton's poetic significance and contended that her artistry is often overlooked: "She is an important poet not only because of her courage in dealing with previously forbidden subjects, but because she can make the language sing. Of what does [her] artistry consist? Not just of her skill in writing traditional poems.... But by artistry, I mean something more subtle than the ability to write formal poems. I mean the artist's sense of where her inspiration lies.... There are many poets of great talent who never take that talent anywhere.... They write poems which any number of people might have written. When Anne Sexton is at the top of her form, she writes a poem which no one else could have written."
- To Bedlam and Part Way Back, Houghton, 1960.
- All My Pretty Ones (also see below), Houghton, 1962.
- Selected Poems, Oxford University Press, 1964.
- Live or Die (also see below), Houghton, 1966.
- (With Thomas Kinsella and Douglas Livingstone) Poems, Oxford University Press, 1968.
- Love Poems (also see below), Houghton, 1969.
- Transformations, Houghton, 1971.
- The Book of Folly, Houghton, 1972.
- O Ye Tongues, Rainbow Press, 1973.
- The Death Notebooks, Houghton, 1974.
- The Awful Rowing toward God, Houghton, 1975.
- 45 Mercy Street (published posthumously) 1976.
- The Heart of Anne Sexton's Poetry (contains All My Pretty Ones, Live or Die, and Love Poems), three volumes, Houghton, 1977.
- Words for Dr. Y: Uncollected Poems with Three Stories, edited by L. G. Sexton, Houghton, 1978.
- Complete Poems, 1981, Houghton, 1981.
- Selected Poems of Anne Sexton, edited by Diane W. Middlebrook and Diana H. George, Houghton, 1988.
- Love Poems of Anne Sexton, introduction by Middlebrook, Houghton, 1989.
- (With Maxine W. Kumin) Eggs of Things (juvenile), Putnam, 1963.
- (With Kumin) More Eggs of Things (juvenile), Putnam, 1964.
- Mercy Street (play; first produced Off-Broadway at American Place Theatre, October 11, 1969)
- (With Kumin) Joey and the Birthday Present (juvenile), McGraw, 1971.
- (With Kumin) The Wizard's Tears (juvenile), McGraw, 1975.
- Anne Sexton: A Self Portrait in Letters (correspondence), edited by L. G. Sexton and Lois Ames, Houghton, 1977.
- No Evil Star: Selected Essays, Interviews, and Prose, edited by Steven E. Colburn, University of Michigan Press, 1985.
- Berry, S. L., Anne Sexton, Creative Education, 1997.
- Concise Dictionary of American Literary Biography: The New Consciousness, 1941-1968, Gale, 1987.
- Contemporary Authors Bibliographical Series, Gale, Volume 2, 1986.
- Contemporary Literary Criticism, Gale, Volume 2, 1974, Volume 4, 1975, Volume 6, 1976, Volume 8, 1978, Volume 10, 1979, Volume 15, 1980, Volume 53, 1989.
- Dictionary of Literary Biography, Volume 5: American Poets since World War II, Gale, 1980.
- George, Diana Hume, Oedipus Anne: The Poetry of Anne Sexton, University of Illinois Press, 1987.
- Hungerford, Edward, editor, Poets in Progress, Northwestern University, 1967.
- McClatchy, J. D., editor, Anne Sexton: The Artist and Her Critics, Indiana University Press, 1978.
- Middlebrook, Diane Wood, Anne Sexton: A Biography, Houghton, 1991.
- Northouse, Cameron and Thomas P. Walsh, Sylvia Plath and Anne Sexton: A Reference Guide, G. K. Hall, 1974.
- Phillips, Robert, The Confessional Poets, Southern Illinois University Press, 1973.
- Sexton, Linda Gray, Searching for Mercy Street: My Journey Back to My Mother, Anne Sexton, Little, Brown, 1994.
- Atlantic, November, 1962.
- Centennial Review, spring, 1975.
- Christian Science Monitor, September 1, 1960.
- Commonweal, Volume 118, November 8, 1991, p. 635.
- Concerning Poetry, spring, 1974.
- English Journal, Volume 83, March 1994, pp. 92, 96.
- Epoch, fall, 1960.
- Harper's, September, 1963.
- Hollins Critic, June, 1984.
- Hudson Review, winter, 1965-66.
- Los Angeles Times, May 3, 1986.
- Moons and Lion Tailes, Volume 2, number 2, 1976.
- Ms., March, 1974.
- Nation, February 23, 1963; September 14, 1974; November 21, 1981; March 23, 1992, p. 385.
- New Boston Review, spring, 1978.
- New Republic, November 22, 1969; October 16, 1971; November 11, 1981; Volume 205, November 4, 1991, p. 32.
- Newsday, March 23, 1975.
- New Statesman, June 16, 1967; Volume 4, November 15, 1991, p. 46.
- Newsweek, Volume 118, July 29, 1991, p. 54.
- New Yorker, April 27, 1963.
- New York Review of Books, June 6, 1968.
- New York Times, March 8, 1969; October 28, 1969; November 2, 1969; November 9, 1969; September 27, 1971; May 18, 1988.
- New York Times Book Review, April 28, 1963; May 30, 1976; July 25, 1976; November 26, 1978; October 18, 1981; August 18, 1991, p. 20.
- Observer Review, May 14, 1967.
- Paris Review, spring, 1971.
- Parnassus: Poetry in Review, Volumes 12-13, numbers 1-2, 1985.
- Poetry, February, 1961, May, 1967.
- Punch, July 5, 1967.
- Reporter, January 3, 1963.
- Saturday Review, December 31, 1966.
- Shenandoah, summer, 1967.
- Society, Volume 29, January-February 1992, pp. 9, 12.
- Time, Volume 138, September 23, 1991, p. 76.
- Times Literary Supplement, May 18, 1967.
- Village Voice, November 6, 1969.
- Virginia Quarterly Review, winter, 1967.
- Washington Post Book World, November 22, 1981.
- AB Bookman's Weekly, December 2, 1974.
- New York Times, October 6, 1974.
- Publishers Weekly, October 28, 1974.
- Time, October 14, 1974.
- Washington Post, October 6, 1974.
Poems By ANNE SEXTON
- All My Pretty Ones
- Crossing the Atlantic
- For Eleanor Boylan Talking with God
- From the Garden
- Her Kind
More poems by Anne Sexton (32 poems)
- In Celebration of My Uterus
- KE 6-8018
- Letter Written on a Ferry While Crossing Long Island Sound
- Menstruation at Forty
- Music Swims Back to Me
- Portrait of an Old Woman on the College Tavern Wall
- Somewhere in Africa
- Sylvia's Death
- The Ballad of the Lonely Masturbator
- The Black Art
- The Double Image
- The Expatriates
- The House
- The Moss of His Skin
- The Operation
- The Room of My Life
- The Starry Night
- The Truth the Dead Know
- The Wedding Night
- Unknown Girl in the Maternity Ward
- Venus and the Ark
- Wanting to Die
- With Mercy for the Greedy
- Woman with Girdle
Audio & PodcastsEssential American Poets
Anne Sexton: Essential American Poets
Archival recordings of poet Anne Sexton, with an introduction to her life and work. Recorded in Boston, Massachusetts, in 1960.
Confessional Poetry Off the Shelf
CA Conrad talks about Anne Sexton’s landscapes of grief.