Harriet

D.A. Powell

Banal Probe

The Blogosphere is, as they say in stand-up comedy, a tough room: so many audience members seem to have shown up just to heckle. It’s strange how people lob remarks from the void—I wonder, often, how those same people might behave at parties.
Of course, a healthy dose of criticism is good and necessary. And it may even be useful to call out the romantic banalities when you see them—though I think anyone who tires of banality should probably avoid the arts altogether.


I am reminded of the old chestnut which I am always unintentionally misquoting: “opinions are like assholes—everybody has at least one.”
I know every Ivy league graduate student has already heard this story (yawn) but I’ll tell it anyway. Once, Frank O’Hara was giving a reading, and a familiar voice shouted from the back of the room, “You’re ruining American poetry, O’Hara.” Not missing a beat, O’Hara replied, “That’s more than you ever did for it, Kerouac.”
Of course, what makes the preceding anecdote noteworthy is the lasting legacy of both participants. Otherwise, it would have just been a silly argument between two people with an exaggerated sense of importance.

Bookmark and Share

11 Comments for “Banal Probe

  1. you gotta be kidding, “D.A.” (if that’s your real name)——
    because you must know they “screen” the comments
    here:
    honest words like O’Hara and Kerouac exchanged
    would never make it through to appear here—

    Posted By: bill knott on June 17, 2008 at 8:53 am
    Report this comment
  2. Or two, silly people with an exaggerated sense of an important argument. I don’t know. A tough room, yes. Like stand-up or magic, enough time has elapsed for the jokes to lose their flare and the secrets of the trick to be made plain. The social construction of legacy is complex and unpredictable. Hindsight having 20/20 vision, isn’t it impossible to know what of blogosphere will be remembered? This exaggerated sense of importance may be your own fear. It’s pretty unlikely any of us will be remembered. Respect for the past seems pretty unfashionable, respect for the present, definitely. And with so much revisionism at work, most of what we celebrate will be a very long, confusing footnote. So have fun.

    Posted By: Aaron Fagan on June 17, 2008 at 11:55 am
    Report this comment
  3. That story is interesting?

    Posted By: Daniel on June 17, 2008 at 12:01 pm
    Report this comment
  4. I wonder if that anecdote is an urban legend. I’ve heard it too but in the version I’ve heard, it’s Gregory Corso, not Kerouac.

    Posted By: Robert on June 17, 2008 at 12:51 pm
    Report this comment
  5. The anecdote was written up in David Lehman’s The Last Avant-Garde: The Making of the New York School of Poets just as Doug, for that is his name, tells it.

    Posted By: Don Share on June 17, 2008 at 4:36 pm
    Report this comment
  6. … and also in Brad Gooch’s City Poet: The Life and Times of Frank O’Hara, p. 322.

    Posted By: Don Share on June 17, 2008 at 4:42 pm
    Report this comment
  7. I didn’t mean for the story to be “interesting.” I meant for it to be illustrative of a kind of critical banter that has some underlying sense of urgency and showmanship. Anybody can fling dirt, apparently. But they can’t all hope to win the hearts and minds of the poetry-reading public. And I’m not signifying any one comment-poster here. It is a general observation on the state of internet conversations.

    Posted By: D. A. Powell on June 17, 2008 at 6:22 pm
    Report this comment
  8. As Don said, the famous incident involving O’Hara and Kerouac (and Gregory Corso) which Doug refers to is by no means an urban legend, and is covered in colorful detail in Brad Gooch’s biography of O’Hara and in David Lehman’s book The Last Avant-Garde (336). Also, Lytle Shaw discusses it in his book Frank O’Hara: The Poetics of Coterie (88-89), and in my own book, Beautiful Enemies: Friendship and Postwar American Poetry, I discuss the O’Hara-Kerouac exchange in relation to an early poem by Amiri Baraka (”Look for You Yesterday, Here You Come Today”) which refers to the incident as well (223-224).

    Posted By: Andrew Epstein on June 18, 2008 at 1:25 pm
    Report this comment
  9. Well, and stop me if you’ve heard this one before:
    [Robert] Lowell did a joint reading with Allen Ginsberg at New York’s St. Marks-in-the-Bowery. The poets shared a podium—a hint that, in the interim, the battlelines had blurred. Gregory Corso rambunctiously heckled Lowell as he read his poem, “Ulysses and Circe.” “Robert, you left out that great line about paranoid,” Corso called out. Lowell responded with a quick “Point taken” and continued. “You treat us like a classroom,” Corso shouted. Lowell responded that he, in fact, was a teacher and tried to let it go at that. The event was shaping up like a lopsided showdown when Ginsberg finally stepped forward and proposed that the crowd collectively invite Corso to “shut up.” They did and Corso amicably exited, boots in hand, wife and baby at his side.
    “The Raw and the Cooked: Robert Lowell and the Beats,” by Tina Cane
    (There’s easily obtainable audio of this incident, too!)

    Posted By: Don Share on June 18, 2008 at 1:51 pm
    Report this comment
  10. What a pain in the ass! Corso, I mean.
    I agree totally about the tough room thing, though. Putting your head above the parapet just seems to invite abuse in some quarters. I think maybe more on these kind of group blogs, where people are reading to see what’s up, and it’s less personal. I’d think twice before blogging for the Guardian, for example.
    It doesn’t happen on my blog, & I’m very grateful. Maybe as it’s just me, if they didn’t like me they wouldn’t read it. But then I never set out to make any big pronouncements; it’s just meant to be a good read.
    As is Harriet, by the way, folks!

    Posted By: Ms Baroque on August 14, 2008 at 10:11 am
    Report this comment
  11. First, comedian Katt Williams (L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E advisory) on the necessary social function of haters; and then, perhaps more loftily, Ms. Adrienne Rich: “Not all of them will love you whichever way you choose.”
    Now theirs might be an argument worth entertaining, were they opinionated, obnoxious guests with exaggerated senses of their own importance! (Which surely describes all literary parties? And reminds me of waiting tables in my twenties, and wondering whether restaurant patrons strew their food around at home as liberally as they seem to do in public.)

    Posted By: unreliable narrator on August 14, 2008 at 3:37 pm
    Report this comment

Comments for this post are closed.

CONTRIBUTING WRITERS

Thom Donovan
Bhanu Kapil
Fred Moten
Craig Santos Perez
Sina Queyras
Sotère Torregian

STAFF WRITERS

Cathy Halley
Michael Marcinkowski
Travis Nichols
Fred Sasaki
Don Share

About Harriet

RECENT COMMENTS

  • Gary Geddes has offered us some amazing anthologies, among other things. Thanks for the reminder. MORE »
    Sina Queyras | 03.18.10
  • WARNING. OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY. DO NOT READ. MENTALLY ILL FAILURE AT WORK. ALERT. ALERT. Do you know ... MORE »
    Eric Landon | 03.18.10
  • I like what Patrick Kavanagh wrote, thanks Don. Poets don't have careers. That's what everybody ... MORE »
    Henry Gould | 03.18.10
  • Hopelessly old-fashioned, yes, but perennially radical. MORE »
    pam lu | 03.18.10
  • Gwynn, You are perfectly right. I should have thought of that. I apologize for that comparison. ... MORE »
    Ron Silliman | 03.18.10

Who or what is a poet critic and why is the... (27)
Graphic Poetry Spotlight: Jai Arun Ravine’s... (3)
To Sonnet, to Son-net, Tuscon Net (54)
Beyond Careerism? (Redistributing Poetic... (30)
Women’s History Month: A Salute (3)

RECENT POSTS

MONTHLY ARCHIVE

CATEGORY ARCHIVE

PREVIOUS WRITERS

Subscribe to the RSS feed.
What is RSS?

IN THIS ISSUE: March 2010

Poetry Magazine

A selection of new work from Dorothea Grossman; new poems by Lavinia Greenlaw, David Yezzi, A.E. Stallings, Gerald Stern, and Dan Gerber; translations of Carlo Betocchi, and Mahmoud Darwish; an Editorial on Ruth Lilly; an exchange between Ilya Kaminsky and Adam Kirsch; an essay by Chen Li; and a review by Daisy Fried.

Chicago Poetry Tour

CHICAGO EVENTS

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker Fri, March 26th, 6:00 PM
Open Books
213 West Institute Place
Free admission

MORE EVENTS »