Harriet

Emily Warn

Christian Conceptual Poetry: Divine Authorship or Appropriation?

Several Christian poets invented conceptual poetry long before Kenny G. All four claim to have composed–with the help of divine inspiration–a popular Christian poem called “Footprints” and all “have memories of the precise moment when they dreamed up these lines.” Rachel Aviv first reported on this “accidental plagiarism” here.
Carl Jung first coined the term “Cryptomnesia” to describe this phenomenon. In a 1905 paper by that name he argues, according to Aviv, “that it’s impossible to know for certain which ideas are one’s own. ‘Our unconsciousness . . . swarms with strange intruders,’ he writes. He accuses Nietzsche of unwittingly copying another’s work, and urges all writers to sift through their memories and locate the origin of every idea before putting it to paper: ” ‘Ask each thought: Do I know you, or are you new?’
Last week the Washington Post, citing Aviv’s story, reported that the authors are now suing one another.

Bookmark and Share

3 Comments for “Christian Conceptual Poetry: Divine Authorship or Appropriation?”

  1. What? Four Christian authors appropriating material and presenting it as their own? That smacks of orthodoxy!

    Posted By: D. A. Powell on June 11, 2008 at 10:27 am
    Report this comment
  2. I have a dry sense of humor.
    It is so dry/ co-workers often said:
    “That’s not funny.”
    My usual response was:
    “it’s not supposed to be.”
    Sometimes, however, I told them
    I got it from the Imp from the Garbage Universe
    and that I was going to kill him when I die.

    Posted By: Brian Salchert on June 11, 2008 at 6:16 pm
    Report this comment
  3. A wonderful opportunity to combine Christian appropriation & Flarf exists at youvebeenleftbehind.com, which offers a “Rapture-triggered” email alert system: in case of rapture, pre-crafted personal entreaties to turn to Christ will be sent to yr loved ones & friends (only $40 for the first year, with reduced subscription rates after that: but, hey, none knows the hour).
    Rest assured that all of Harriet is on my list. Enjoy yr thousand years of darkness, suckas!

    Posted By: Michael Robbins on June 11, 2008 at 6:19 pm
    Report this comment

Comments for this post are closed.

CONTRIBUTING WRITERS

Thom Donovan
Bhanu Kapil
Fred Moten
Craig Santos Perez
Sina Queyras
Sotère Torregian

STAFF WRITERS

Cathy Halley
Michael Marcinkowski
Travis Nichols
Fred Sasaki
Don Share

About Harriet

RECENT COMMENTS

  • One big reason to have a "career" here in the U.S. is health insurance. ... MORE »
    Joshua | 03.19.10
  • Thank you Henry. MORE »
    SherylLuna | 03.19.10
  • "there are many ways to be in the academy outside of teaching creative writing" So true. ... MORE »
    Brenda Schmidt | 03.19.10
  • Glad to be of help with your career - MORE »
    Henry Gould | 03.19.10
  • Nikki, What you're describing resonates with me. I wrote for many years before I took ... MORE »
    Sina Queyras | 03.19.10

To Sonnet, to Son-net, Tuscon Net (55)
All sides now: a correspondence with Lisa... (4)
Who or what is a poet critic and why is the... (27)
Graphic Poetry Spotlight: Jai Arun Ravine’s... (3)
Beyond Careerism? (Redistributing Poetic... (30)

RECENT POSTS

MONTHLY ARCHIVE

CATEGORY ARCHIVE

PREVIOUS WRITERS

Subscribe to the RSS feed.
What is RSS?

IN THIS ISSUE: March 2010

Poetry Magazine

A selection of new work from Dorothea Grossman; new poems by Lavinia Greenlaw, David Yezzi, A.E. Stallings, Gerald Stern, and Dan Gerber; translations of Carlo Betocchi, and Mahmoud Darwish; an Editorial on Ruth Lilly; an exchange between Ilya Kaminsky and Adam Kirsch; an essay by Chen Li; and a review by Daisy Fried.

CHICAGO EVENTS

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker Fri, March 26th, 6:00 PM
Open Books
213 West Institute Place
Free admission

MORE EVENTS »