Harriet

Travis Nichols

w00t vs. harumph

Galleycat wonders ablog if social networking sites like Goodreads can supplant the studied expertise of professional book critics.
Martial Flourish

VS.

Or something like that.
It’s an interesting question not just for the Steinbeckian pre-teens in the UK or dead Russian novelists, but for the contemporary poetry tribes, too, since poetry criticism in major media outlets is pretty slim, and seeming to get slimmer or more fatuous by the year.
I get emails every day from people asking me to connect with them on Goodreads, to look at their updated Goodreads page, or to just read a goddamn book already. But I have yet to get involved because I have nagging icky feelings about the whole process.
I’d rather ask someone face to face what she’s reading than go check online, but I also like to forage for berries after a long morning of waxing my handlebar moustache, so perhaps I’m not so au courant.
Talking with a friend at Open Books the other day, we both agreed it would be nice to feel like we could ride the crest of the present’s wave with a giddy optimism, but most of the time our little rafts feel swamped.
But as I type this, I think I should go check out my dormant Goodreads account to find out what my friends have been reading, how many stars they’re giving what, and if they’ve uploaded a super cute picture to their profile (OMG! They totally have!)

Bookmark and Share

Comments are closed.

Comments for this post are closed.

CONTRIBUTING WRITERS

Thom Donovan
Bhanu Kapil
Fred Moten
Craig Santos Perez
Sina Queyras
Sotère Torregian

STAFF WRITERS

Cathy Halley
Michael Marcinkowski
Travis Nichols
Fred Sasaki
Don Share

About Harriet

RECENT COMMENTS

  • Yes, I agree, Joshua. I understand that this is a big motivating factor for poets ... MORE »
    Sina Queyras | 03.19.10
  • One big reason to have a "career" here in the U.S. is health insurance. ... MORE »
    Joshua | 03.19.10
  • Thank you Henry. MORE »
    SherylLuna | 03.19.10
  • "there are many ways to be in the academy outside of teaching creative writing" So true. ... MORE »
    Brenda Schmidt | 03.19.10
  • Glad to be of help with your career - MORE »
    Henry Gould | 03.19.10

To Sonnet, to Son-net, Tuscon Net (55)
All sides now: a correspondence with Lisa... (4)
Who or what is a poet critic and why is the... (27)
Graphic Poetry Spotlight: Jai Arun Ravine’s... (3)
Beyond Careerism? (Redistributing Poetic... (30)

RECENT POSTS

MONTHLY ARCHIVE

CATEGORY ARCHIVE

PREVIOUS WRITERS

Subscribe to the RSS feed.
What is RSS?

IN THIS ISSUE: March 2010

Poetry Magazine

A selection of new work from Dorothea Grossman; new poems by Lavinia Greenlaw, David Yezzi, A.E. Stallings, Gerald Stern, and Dan Gerber; translations of Carlo Betocchi, and Mahmoud Darwish; an Editorial on Ruth Lilly; an exchange between Ilya Kaminsky and Adam Kirsch; an essay by Chen Li; and a review by Daisy Fried.

CHICAGO EVENTS

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker

Poetry Off the Shelf: David Baker Fri, March 26th, 6:00 PM
Open Books
213 West Institute Place
Free admission

MORE EVENTS »