More Lying Loving Facts, You Sort ’Em Out

By Arthur Vogelsang b. 1942 Arthur Vogelsang
For a long time the Spanish from Spain   
Who came here became slightly insane   
In a special way and just a little.   
You can try this yourself.   
Walk farther than you can into the forest in New York   
So it’s a toss-up whether or not you know the way back.   
For you there’s going to be a smidge of confusion, a glow of fear   
That smells like burning rye toast,   
And the illusion that you are the only person alive   
On the earth. You will probably have the second illusion   
That no one likes you, which doesn’t jibe with the first illusion   
Of no other people. This was about the extent of it, for the Spanish,   
They felt all that just a few hours a week, but every week at home,   
Living in, say, small San Francisco,   
Which made thinking slow and hard at these times,   
But if you try this yourself in the deep woods   
You’ll see you can still think enough   
And you’ll remember your way back to the loving arms   
Of your wife, husband, or mother, in Rochester. (Yes,   
You could try it as a child, but please don’t.)   
The Spanish had a purpose to walk east inland to the Sierras, the gold.   
The Indians said there were five hills and two mountains   
Entirely of gold and you had to wear ferns dangling before your eyes   
Like sunglasses when you got near the mountains.   
The hills, they said, were not so bright.   
The Spanish thought this was bullshit   
But were having trouble with the coast (where   
They truly believed the gold was) which was that boats   
Could not travel north and south even as fast as people walking   
Because the Pacific coast was opposing currents (you made   
Half a mile an hour in the water with biggest sail).   
An expedition of thirty Spaniards from Spain (living   
In small San Francisco) walked east inland toward what’s now Mariposa.   
It means butterfly. In that place, the shivering feathery
Insects rose from the ground and blacked out the sun.   
The sky had no room for more butterflies so the leftovers attached to the trees,   
Making the trees appear like ragged trees.   
Look up the other way, the explorers said to each other, but   
That way, when they did, was no blue sky but darkness of orange insects   
That did not fly in clouds but were the sky,   
So any forward motion by the thirty men seemed, not seemed   
Did make the sky covered each inch   
With the thin trembling insects, brown or green or orange,   
But as a whole a black ceiling with little light between them and the men,   
Who thought slow and hard but did think, and so returned   
To small San Francisco where no one believed them but understood   
The illusion because when they asked the thirty men   
What such an encounter with butterflies felt like, the men described   
Feeling the way all the colonists and explorers and priests and women   
Felt a few hours each week at home—   
Fear making the olfactory illusion of burning rye toast hand   
In hand with the illusion of being the only one   
And the simultaneous but contradictory illusion   
That no one likes you. How could everybody hate you   
If there was no everybody? Or even anybody.   
Well there was a way to fix this   
And we use it now around here (I   
Mean in New York and California and Nevada and Hawaii,   
Not just in my house) which is to wrap our loving arms   
Around each other. It works very well   
And I know you’ve tried it.   
The Spanish from Spain brought virtuous women   
Over for that purpose only (you don’t think the virtuous babes looked   
For gold, did you?) and it worked very well   
Except the women were worse, I mean much worse,
Not just specially a little insane and needed   
The loving arms much more than the men.   
They needed longer sessions and more sessions.   
What’s more, if the expedition of thirty butterfly   
Illusionists had gone six miles further,   
They would have seen silver sticking out of the ground   
Like glass after a four-car accident on a street in Rochester.   
But for many decades the promise of the waiting loving arms,   
Versus the unacceptable illusion of the butterflies   
Forming the entire black sky, kept them near the coasts.   
When you put down this book, you could decide   
For yourself if it is true that wrapping loving arms around   
Somebody is as temporarily powerful as I’ve made it   
Out to be or is possibly permanently powerful or is an illusion   
Like the massed feathery insects which were absolute.

Source: Poetry (February 2009).

MORE FROM THIS ISSUE

This poem originally appeared in the February 2009 issue of Poetry magazine

February 2009
 Arthur  Vogelsang

Biography

Arthur Vogelsang was born in Baltimore, Maryland, and earned a BA in English at the University of Maryland, an MA from the Writing Seminars at the Johns Hopkins University, and an MFA the University of Iowa Writers’ Workshop. From 1973-2006 Vogelsang served as an editor of the American Poetry Review. Vogelsang’s editing career also includes Metro Book Co. (1983-2002) and the Ark River Review (1971-80), and he has taught at the . . .

Continue reading this biography

Poem Categorization

SUBJECT Relationships, Men & Women, Social Commentaries, History & Politics

POET’S REGION U.S., Western

Poetic Terms Free Verse

Report a problem with this poem


Your results will be limited to content that appeared in Poetry magazine.

Search Every Issue of Poetry

Originally appeared in Poetry magazine.

This poem has learning resources.

This poem is good for children.

This poem has related video.

This poem has related audio.