Uncategorized

Hello Again & Harriet & Comments

Originally Published: April 30, 2009

This seems like as good of a time as any to re-introduce myself as a Harriet citizen, so here I go:

Hi.  How's it going?

As many of you know, for the past eleven months  I've been a contributing writer here on Harriet and editorial consultant for Poetryfoundation.org.  This month, I've started work as the new associate editor.  I hope to live up to the great work the site has done in the past, and I hope we can head out in new and interesting directions together as well.  The to-do list is long, but I'm quite excited to get started.

First up on the to-do list?  Comments!

Let's talk about the comments.

First of all, thanks to everyone for their suggestions and input over the past week in response to Cathy’s post, “A Few Harriet Statistics.” The response has been instructive in many ways, and we're grateful to have had it here.

As Cathy stated, we're constantly trying to strike the balance between lively, engaged discussion and roller-derby free-for all on the site (Harriet wouldn’t be Harriet without a bit of both).  To that end, we’ll be implementing new design features in the coming weeks, the first of which is multiple comment threads.  Commenters now have the option to either reply to the general thread of a post, or to reply directly to a previous comment.  As Annie noted, some of the seemingly digressive streams are incredibly generative, so we encourage you to thread deeply and often (that sounds like some kind of innuendo, but it’s not, I swear!).

We’ve also posted the comments policy for all new users to see as they sign up.  It reads:

PoetryFoundation.org welcomes comments that foster dialogue and cultivate an open community on the site. We reserve the right to delete comments that contain offensive language or personal attacks. Repeated violation of this policy will result in restricted use of the site. The first time a person comments on the site, his or her comment must be approved by the site moderators. Subsequent comments will appear on the site automatically. Please note: We require comments to include a name and email address. By submitting a comment, you give the Poetry Foundation the right to publish it.

It follows that once you have been approved, the burden is on you to meet these standards.  Most everyone does, and for that we are extremely grateful.  There are, of course, exceptions, and so it's worth repeating: We reserve the right to delete comments that contain offensive language or personal attacks. Repeated violation of this policy will result in restricted use of the site.

Commenting on Harriet is not an inalienable right.  If you cannot adhere to the stated policy, then your use will be restricted.  When and if this happens, it will be after one of the site administrators makes a subjective decision. We all have different standards of decency, but this does not mean all standards of decency are valid in this particular forum.  There are plenty of places online and in the world without such policies; Feel free to take your comment somewhere else.

And while it's true that Catullus existed, and language is a great mutable thing we should celebrate in all its various forms, we have certain standards here, and we hope they help foster and encourage conversation, and so we're going to enforce them.

We also hope that Harriet continues to be a valuable place to discuss poetry online.  Thanks to everyone who helps make it so.

Travis Nichols is the author of two books of poetry: Iowa (2010, Letter Machine Editions) and See Me...

Read Full Biography